A community of support

Early Start Changes make the press

September 21st, 2009 Posted in Changes to CES

Anyone feeling similarly or differently?

-Karen Baas, Infant Development Association of CA

O’Brien: How one agency’s cuts point to California’s bleak future

By Chris O’Brien
Mercury News Columnist

I am feeling more bleak than ever about the future of my adopted home state.

Years of budget lunacy in Sacramento culminated in a series of catastrophic cuts made this summer. It’s unlikely that any part of state government escaped the hatchet. I’ll leave it to historians to sort out just how badly we were failed by our governor and legislators.

But it’s all too easy to forget, amid all the talks of billions cut here and billions cut there, the impact of each cut, and how those cuts may eventually make our dire budget situation even worse. This situation did more than just demonstrate the madness of the short-term thinking that drove the cuts. It provided a stark example of how, by choosing to focus on cutting rather than investing, we, the people and the politicians, could end up paying more in the long run to deal with our problems.

In this case, I’m talking about the brutal reductions made to early intervention services for at-risk and developmentally delayed children under the age of 3.

I happen to know a fair bit about this subject because my son received these state-funded services between the ages of 18 months and 3 years. Liam is now 6 years old and has been diagnosed as high-functioning autistic. Thanks to those early intervention services, he’s now in first grade at a mainstream elementary school.

Understanding the impact of these cuts is difficult because the state’s system for providing these services is complex. But let me walk you through the maze.

At the top is the California Health and Human Services Agency. Under the CHHS is the Department of Developmental Services. The DDS doles out money to 21 nonprofit regional centers that serve 244,000 adults and children with various degrees of disabilities.

Back in 2003, when Liam was found to have speech and other developmental delays, we were referred to the Regional Center of the East Bay. Through the regional center, Liam received speech and occupational therapy that put him on the path to closing the development gap with his peers.

But it’s just such services that are now being cut. And because I know how invaluable they are, my heart breaks for all the families that won’t receive them.

The folks who run DDS and an advisory task force have been heroically trying to make the best of a horrific situation. The agency projected that the number of folks it would serve this year would increase by 12,800. But rather than getting a budget increase to cover that growth, which DDS estimated would run about $384 million, the agency got a bump of only $22 million to its $4.7 billion budget, so it needs to find savings to make up the difference. The agency convened a large number of stakeholders to try to find the most humane solution.

“How can we do the least harm?” said Julia Mullen, deputy director of the community services and support division at DDS. Perhaps we need to adopt that phrase as our state motto.

The political insistence on cutting put the department in the impossible position of trying to decide how to split the baby. For which group of people with autism, epilepsy or cerebral palsy do you reduce services? The solution was painful. The department focused on three categories of kids it serves. The first are kids who are at risk, perhaps because of a problem at birth, but have not shown a delay. California was one of only six states that served these kids. But no more.

The second category are kids who come to the regional centers after age 2 and are less than 50 percent delayed in one area, such as speech.

Both groups of kids will no longer receive direct services such as speech, occupational or physical therapy.

Fortunately, the agency managed to shift some money around to create a new prevention program for these kids. The new program won’t provide services, but the kids will be assigned a case manager to watch them closely to see if they’re getting worse, and if so, pull them into the system.

“We wanted to have a safety net,” Mullen said. “To make sure they did not fall through the cracks.”

This carefully thought-out plan has been further complicated by our knife-wielding governor’s decision to make a last-minute line-item cut that sliced another $50 million off the DDS budget. The agency is still weighing how to take that into account if it withstands a legal challenge.

From a moral perspective, the choice forced on the agency is indefensible. Rather than taking aggressive preventive action, the department must now gamble with these kids’ lives and hope as few as possible develop more severe delays.

From a treatment perspective, you’d be hard pressed to find any expert who would advocate a “let’s see what happens” approach. Mullen said the agency is going to be extremely vigilant when it comes to watching these kids for any signs they’re regressing.

But beyond all that, I’m troubled by the potential economics. Researchers are clear that early and preventive treatment saves money down the road. Conversely, by waiting, fewer kids will come into the system but they will likely have more severe issues, and thus will likely cost more to treat.

“The state is essentially disinvesting in young children,” said Steven Barnett, co-director of the National Institute for Early Education Research at Rutgers University. “And that will result in more expenditures later on.”

So this is the economic bargain our governor and Legislature have asked us to make: Let’s hope that the higher expense of waiting to treat fewer kids doesn’t eat up all the money we’re saving by cutting early intervention services.

I can’t help but think what my family would have done had we been told that our son wouldn’t be eligible because he was only 40 percent delayed. Because our insurance didn’t cover such direct therapy, we probably would have borrowed thousands of dollars to pay for services out of pocket.

This is the grim choice the state will be forcing on to thousands of families. So let’s be clear about one thing: These cuts are not really cuts. As a society, we will still end up with costs, directly or indirectly, down the road. These kids will go to schools, where they may require more services or support. Or they’ll be less productive when they grow up and can’t get jobs. Our failure to invest now may cost us more later, making it even more daunting to solve the budget mess. And if we can’t fix that, the quality of life that’s critical to our economy will continue to decline.

And in the end, this is only one of many such cuts enacted. Repeated over the billions of dollars sliced from the state budget, I wonder if the governor or any of our legislators know how much the cuts today will end up really costing tomorrow.

In truth, none of us knows. And that’s what has made me doubtful that the Golden State will ever regain its luster.

  1. 7,036 Responses to “Early Start Changes make the press”

  2. By Ahmed on Jan 13, 2017

    They will have a look at your credit score history, and need to ensure that at the very least the last three payments on your
    pupil loans have been made on time.

  3. By tanning pros and cons on Jan 13, 2017

    Enjoyed every bit of your blog.Much thanks again. Awesome.

  4. By scjp on Jan 13, 2017

    Really enjoyed this article post.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.

  5. By affordable paper writing service on Jan 14, 2017

    Wow, great article post.Much thanks again. Will read on…

  6. By Mobile beauty salon Basingstoke on Jan 14, 2017

    Im obliged for the post. Really Cool.

  7. By Chung cu sunshine riverside tay ho on Jan 14, 2017

    Thank you, I’ve just been looking for information approximately this subject for a while and
    yours is the greatest I’ve found out so far. However, what concerning
    the conclusion? Are you sure concerning the supply?

  8. By http://amandajaynephoto.com on Jan 14, 2017

    Perfect work you have done, this website is really cool with
    good information.

  9. By Evangeline Cobb on Jan 14, 2017

    Загружайте приложение прямо сейчас и воспользуйтесь всеми его преимуществами!

  10. By click here on Jan 14, 2017

    Asking questions are really nice thing if you are not understanding anything entirely, but this paragraph gives
    nice understanding yet.

  11. By PITy roczne Jelenia Góra on Jan 14, 2017

    Really enjoyed this article.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.

  12. By PlayStation 5 Release date and Features on Jan 14, 2017

    Enjoyed every bit of your blog.

  13. By hay day forum game center on Jan 14, 2017

    😀 Some ideas of the Bouncy Castle!!

  14. By Mu Origin hack on Jan 14, 2017

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts about iphone mu origin hack.

  15. By loftplan on Jan 15, 2017

    I am glad to be among the visitors on this excellent internet site (:, appreciate it for posting .

  16. By consultancy on Jan 15, 2017

    Helpful info. Fortunate me I discovered your web
    site unintentionally, and I am shocked why this twist of fate didn’t happened
    in advance! I bookmarked it.

  17. By Hemorrhoid Medicine on Jan 15, 2017

    Thanks , I’ve recently been searching for information approximately this subject for a while and yours
    is the greatest I have discovered till now. However, what concerning the conclusion? Are
    you positive concerning the supply?

  18. By Download Mp3 on Jan 15, 2017

    Seriously extremely excellent contribution, I really depend on up-dates of your stuff.

  19. By Gismo Trends on Jan 15, 2017


  20. By Lloyd on Jan 15, 2017

    always i used to read smaller content which also clear their motive,
    and that is also happening with this paragraph which I am reading at
    this time.

  21. By Sausalito Ferry Schedule on Jan 15, 2017

    I am in fact happy to read this website posts which includes tons of
    useful facts, thanks for providing such information.

  22. By loftplan on Jan 16, 2017

    some genuinely choice content on this internet site , saved to my bookmarks .

  23. By hip hop on Jan 16, 2017

    Fantastic blog. Will read on…

  24. By mold inspectors on Jan 16, 2017

    Say, you got a nice post.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.

  25. By advertising apps on Jan 16, 2017

    wow, awesome article. Will read on…

  26. By login to icloud on Jan 16, 2017

    Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog article.Thanks Again.

  27. By iowaska on Jan 16, 2017

    A big thank you for your article post.Much thanks again. Keep writing.

  28. By Eva on Jan 16, 2017

    Hi there friends, good article and nice arguments commented here, I am in fact enjoying by these.

  29. By age spots removal naturally on Jan 16, 2017

    I really like and appreciate your blog. Will read on…

  30. By make money from home on Jan 16, 2017

    This unusual demand comes from moms who’ve issue breast feeding so they purchase the milk on-line.

  31. By Latashia on Jan 16, 2017

    I am really enjoying the theme/design of your web site.

    Do you ever run into any web browser compatibility problems?
    A handful of my blog visitors have complained about my
    blog not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Firefox.
    Do you have any recommendations to help fix this issue?

  32. By search engine optimisation on Jan 16, 2017

    My partner аnd Ӏ stumbled oѵer here from a different paɡe
    and thought I should check things out. I like what I see so now i am following yⲟս.
    Look forward to finding out abоut your web page repeatedly.

    SEO Expert with 20+ yᥱars. I work in areas as diverse as
    search engіne optimization, social mediа marketing, email marketing and digital
    marketing. I know what works because I stay on top of the industry.

    Fοr me, it’s not just a job — it’s a driνing passion.

  33. By 第1位獲得 一部予約販売 on Jan 16, 2017

    !私がしてきた先に行くとあなたを与えるために| 勇気勇気今、最終的に得たしながら長い時間 以下のためのあなたのブログからシャウトアウト 送信!ちょうどしたかった言及 仕事仕事 偉大な良い幻想を追いつきます!

  34. By 一部予約販売 送料無料&高速配送 on Jan 16, 2017

    ファンタスティックビート! ウェブサイト、どのようにあなたがあなたを修正しながら弟子を|私はに希望したい でき私はブログに加入しますか?アカウント|私は、許容できる取引助け助け。私がされていた小さな |明るいクリアなこのブロードキャストの知り合いビットは提供提供 アイデア

  35. By 一部予約販売 特価2015 on Jan 16, 2017

    こんにちは! あなたを伝える私は素早く叫びを与え、したかったので、ここでコメント|これは私の第1は、あなたのブログの投稿。同じ対処越える他のブログ/ウェブサイト/フォーラムトピック |あなたはお勧めを示唆していることができますか? 感謝を!

  36. By jaki szampon na wypadanie włosów on Jan 16, 2017

    The length of hair that you are able to grow is controlled by the duration of the growing phase, which varies between individuals.

  37. By dien dan seo on Jan 16, 2017

    It’s awesome for me to have a web site, which is valuable designed
    for my know-how. thanks admin

Post a Comment